GEOPOLITICS IN AMERICAS

Trump's Latin America allies recalibrate after US election earthquake

Trump's midterm election drubbing has heightened scrutiny of his dealings in Latin America, complicating life for his right-wing allies who bet on close ties with the White House. 

Javier Milei and Donald Trump at the Shield of the Americas Summit in March 2026. Foto: cedoc/perfil

US President Donald Trump's midterm election drubbing has heightened scrutiny of his dealings in Latin America and complicated life for right-wing allies who bet on close ties with the White House. 

In his second term, Trump has mounted an all-out bid to pull Latin America into Washington's orbit. His administration has toppled the leader of Venezuela, bombed alleged drug-smuggling boats in the Caribbean, backed right-wing candidates in elections and wielded tariffs to pressure partners. 

But Trump's success in cultivating a bloc of ideological allies is now facing growing headwinds.

In Colombia, Foreign Minister Omar Bula last week apologised profusely for a string of past social media posts attacking leading Democrats, saying the remarks had been "inappropriate and disrespectful." 

A constructive relationship with both parties was "essential" he added.

Fernando Cvitanic, a professor of international relations at the Universidad de La Sabana in Bogotá, said the governments of Argentina and Colombia had taken a "highly risky gamble" by openly favoring the Republican party.

From now on, he said, "relations will not be as smooth as they once were."

 

Changing of the guard

Analysts say that when the Democratic majority is sworn in in January, Trump's policies and his alliances will come under fierce examination.

"We will see more scrutiny, more oversight, and a greater push for accountability," said Abelardo Rodríguez Sumano, an international studies researcher at the Universidad Iberoamericana in Mexico City.

Michael Shifter, a senior fellow at The Inter-American Dialogue think tank in Washington, told AFP that Trump's bet on right-leaning leaders in Latin America had begun unraveling even before the midterm rout.

From Argentina to Peru, Colombia and Chile, these leaders are facing sliding popularity as they battle to fulfill promises to tackle economic stagnation, crime and corruption.

Then, Brazil's veteran leftist President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva "bucked the regional trend" with a shock win over right-wing senator Flavio Bolsonaro in an election last month.

"The midterm election results should be a wake-up call for the region's leaders who have aligned with Trump but not the US," said Shifter.

Their "personal affinity with Trump will not suffice to pursue a productive relationship with the US and defend their national interests."

 

Transparency in Venezuela

Two policies that are likely to come under particular scrutiny are Trump's activities in Venezuela and his "Shield of the Americas" coalition.

Since US forces captured President Nicolas Maduro in January, Trump's administration has backed interim leader Delcy Rodriguez, who has bent to Washington's demands and given the US control over a large portion of the country's vast oil reserves.

Mariano de Alba, an associate fellow at the International Institute for Strategic Studies in London, told AFP that Democrats "want to know every detail regarding the agreements signed with Venezuela."

This includes who signed them, their ties to Trump and whether there are any conflicts of interest.

Meanwhile, Democrats are expected to continue to push for elections and the restoration of democracy in Venezuela, aided by recently returned opposition leader and Nobel laureate María Corina Machado.

 

Shields and strikes

Trump's hardline, militarised counter-narcotics strategy is also sure to be probed by Democrats.

Lawmakers have already called for formal investigations into strikes on alleged drug-smuggling boats in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific, which have killed about 235 people, according to an AFP tally.

The Trump administration has not provided definitive evidence that the vessels it has targeted are involved in drug-trafficking and rights groups have warned the strikes may amount to extrajudicial killings.

"Beyond oversight and accountability, we might also see a shift in approach, particularly regarding human rights violations and even the loss of life in the Caribbean," said Sumano.

Questions are being asked too about Trump's Shield of the Americas – with a Marvel-style logo – which brings together more than a dozen countries, including Argentina, Colombia, El Salvador and Ecuador, to combat drug cartels.

Notably absent were left-wing leaders from the region's two biggest economies, Mexico and Brazil.

Brazil, which has had strained diplomatic ties with Washington under Trump, is hoping the Democrat victory will strengthen more moderate voices in his administration.

This could present an "opportunity for a pragmatic normalisation" of ties between the two countries, a Brazilian government source said on condition of anonymity.